Based on an exclusive piece by NYC Newswire, Connecticut Muffin will call it quits after over 20 years in Clinton Hill, closing for good on Saturday, November 29, 2025. Located at Myrtle Avenue and Clinton Avenue, the coffee shop has been central to the neighborhood since its 2003 opening. The recent rent spike made it unsustainable for the business to continue.
Rent Increase Shuts Down Beloved Café
NYC Newswire reports that employees learned the rent would go up by $4,000 per month, putting the shop in a tough position financially. The café’s absence will be felt by residents who valued its reliable offerings and cozy setting.
Connecticut Muffin on Myrtle Ave Clinton Hill Brooklyn Final Day Counter by NYC Newswire
A Key Part of Clinton Hill Mornings
For years, Connecticut Muffin provided everything from morning coffee to fresh-baked pastries. Pratt Institute students, local parents, and neighborhood veterans frequented the shop, making it a natural gathering spot. Its steadfast presence cemented its place in the neighborhood’s heart.
Staff Moving to Other Locations
Even though the Clinton Hill outpost is closing, regulars can still meet their favorite staff at other Connecticut Muffin locations across Brooklyn:
-
Park Slope: 423 7th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY
-
Ditmas Park: 1106 Cortelyou Road, Brooklyn, NY
Locals can stop by these venues to reconnect with the familiar team.
Connecticut Muffin on Myrtle Ave Clinton Hill Brooklyn Final Day Interior by NYC Newswire
Closure Saddens Locals
The closure has prompted an outpouring of disappointment from patrons. As one frequent customer put it to NYC Newswire:
“I’m really going to miss this place. It’s my go-to spot at least 4 days per week. There are other coffee shops around but none like Connecticut Muffin. The staff has always been pleasant and the products have always been consistent. It’s a shame that we continue to lose great neighborhood spots because of high rents.”
End of an Era in Clinton Hill
Many expect to visit on November 29 to share a final coffee and say goodbye. The closing of Connecticut Muffin is part of a wider issue facing independent local businesses hit hard by rising commercial costs.
Subscribe to the ClintonHill.com Newsletter to receive news, event updates, and more about Clinton Hill.
